Sustainable and Alternate Fuels for Waste Collection

Oct 19, 2022 | Collection and Transportation Technology, ISWA blog, ISWA news

ISWA’s Collection and Transport Technologies working group commissioned this report under ISWA’s mission to promote and develop sustainable, professional waste management worldwide.  The concept was to benchmark international best practices and observe how municipalities in different countries are evolving their fleets and what technologies are being considered.

 

The need to consider climate change action and improving air quality within cities would need radical changes to fleet operation and this report looks at case studies a in number of municipalities around the world, in their moves from conventional to alternative fuels for waste collection.

 

The project gathered data on current practices, as well as options being considered and any obstacles to moving from conventional fuels.  This was broad brush gathering of data, with the intention to delve into more detail on those that were developing alternatives in a variety of fuel options.

The working group aimed to cover all the options: hydrogen; electric; hydrogenated vegetable oil (HVO); hybrid; biofuel and compressed natural/liquid gas (CNG, CLG).

 

Table 1: Summary of key points for each fuel type

 

Fuel type Key benefits Key challenges

 

Electric

  • Zero emissions
  • Improved driving conditions
  • Lower operating costs
  • High vehicle capital cost
  • Charging infrastructure
  • Vehicle supply chain
  • Battery range
  • Other environmental impacts (e.g., battery production)
Hydrogen fuel
  • Zero emissions
  • Increased travel range
  • Speed of fuelling
  • Vehicle life
  • Hydrogen supply
  • High vehicle capex
  • Vehicle supply chain
Hydrogen / diesel hybrid combustion
  • Moderate capex for conversion
  • Ease of use
  • Hydrogen supply
  • Conversion considerations
  • Limited carbon reductions
Natural gas
  • Reduced emissions
  • Lower fuel cost
  • Similar performance
  • High vehicle capital cost
  • Fuelling infrastructure
HVO
  • Ease of use
  • Lower emissions
  • Fuel supply
  • Fuel cost
  • Performance efficiency

 

The study identified a number of areas where further work may be of use to municipalities seeking to adopt alternative fuel vehicles:

  • End of life vehicle management – what happens to the vehicles at the end of their frontline service: resale / reuse, decommissioning, retrofit, recycling of components
  • Life cycle analysis – the full environmental impacts associated with the vehicle manufacture, supporting infrastructure, fuel / power generation, vehicle use and end of life
  • Supply chain capacity – an assessment of the capacity of the vehicle supply market to meet potential demand, particularly taking into account lead times.

In summary, the report gives an insight into the experiences of municipalities operating alternative fuel vehicles for waste collection. The findings may be of interest to others seeking to adopt such fuels.

Note: the information in this report and the findings of this study were correct at the time of undertaking (September 2021 to March 2022); however, this is a rapidly developing area, that is subject to change.

 

share this article

ISWA’s latest

All news

Filter: